Lost in Space and Time


“People like us, who believe in physics, know that the distinction between past, present, and future is only a stubbornly persistent illusion.”

~ Albert Einstein

From a human perspective, physics has a problem with time. We have no difficulty defining a special moment called “now” that is distinct from the past and the future, but our theories cannot capture the essence of the moment. The laws of nature deal only with what happens between certain time intervals.

David Mermin of Cornell University claims to have solved this problem using a principle similar to the one he and others have applied to quantum theory (see main story). We should simply abandon the notion that an objectively determinable space-time exists.

Instead of forming a series of slices or layers that from some viewpoint correspond to a “now” or “then”, Mermin’s space-time is a mesh of intersecting filaments relating to the experiences of different people (arxiv.org/abs/1312.7825). “Why promote space-time from a 4D diagram, which is a useful conceptual device, to a real essence?” he asks. “By identifying my abstract system with an objective reality, I fool myself into regarding it as the arena in which I live my life.”

Things such as an interval of time or the dimensionality of space, after all, are not stamped on nature for us to read off; a newborn baby has no conception of them. They are merely useful abstractions we develop to account for what clocks and rulers do. Some of these high-level abstractions we construct for ourselves as we grow up, others were constructed by geniuses and have been passed on to us in school or in books, says Mermin. “And some of them, like quantum states, most of us never learn at all.”

Matthew Chalmers is a freelance writer based in Bristol, UK, From issue 2968 of New Scientist magazine, page 32-35.

Below is a clip of Brian Greene, Professor of Physics and Mathematics at Columbia University, presents interesting information about the nature of space-time, including an explanation of how past, present, and future all exist in the now.

A brief video with David Eagleman who explains how the human brain understands time, and why it may not always be as it seems.


Decolonizing Science

Article by

We are witnessing a resurgence of indigenous knowledge and growing acknowledgement of its scientific value worldwide

Wholeness & Fragmentation

Video with

The problem with our "civilized" and compartmentalized ways of thinking, which is fragmented.

Assembly Theory

Article by

Bold New 'Theory of Everything' Could Unite Physics And Evolution

The Star Compass: kāpehu whetū

Article by

Indigenous Polynesian technology for navigating using the stars

#55 Cerebrospinal Fluid

Podcast with

A fascinating lecture on the potential mystical properties of fluid in our bodies

The Convergence of Science and Spirituality

Video with ,

A video version of our popular Sounds of SAND Podcast episode

A 9-minute journey inside a black hole

Video with

Ever wonder what would happen if we got sucked into a black hole? Turns out we could live in it — if it was big enough.

A New Kind of Symmetry Shakes Up Physics

Article by

So-called “higher symmetries” are illuminating everything from particle decays to the behavior of complex quantum systems

Support SAND with a Donation

Science and Nonduality is a nonprofit organization. Your donation goes directly towards the development of our vision and the growth of our community.
Thank you for your support!