Physicists Entangle Particles Across Time

Article by

“People like us, who believe in physics, know that the distinction between past, present and future is only a stubbornly persistent illusion.”
~ Albert Einstein

If you thought that the quantum phenomena of particles being “entangled” across vast distances of space was strange, that’s nothing. Israeli physicists have shown that they can link particles together so that measuring one affects the other, even if the particles never existed at the same time.

Entanglement is one of the stranger features of quantum mechanics — although there are so many to choose from that it’s hard to decide. Two quantum particles, such as photons, can be linked together — entangled — so that measuring one causes the other to “collapse” into a certain state. This occurs even when the entangled particles are far apart.

Several years ago, researchers from Hebrew University of Jerusalem showed that it’s also possible to entangle particles across time. While entanglement usually involves creating two particles at the same time, the researchers were able to entangle two particles that never overlapped temporally.

Their research was published in 2013 in Physical Review Letters. To accomplish this feat, the researchers used a process known as “entanglement swapping.” This technique involves researchers firing a laser at a special crystal to create two pairs of entangled photons — 1 and 2, and 3 and 4. At this point, photons 1 and 4 are not entangled. Due to the uncertainty of quantum theory, photons can exist in two states at the same time — polarized vertically and horizontally. When researchers measure the photon, it randomly takes on, or collapses into, one of those states.

Researchers can use this behavior of quantum particles to entangle photons 2 and 3 in a process called “projective measurement.” This measurement entangles the photons, but also destroys them. This can also be done in a certain way that the measurement entangles photons 1 and 4. Adrian Cho describes this on Science Magazine  as two pairs of gears being connected to form a four-gear chain.

In recent years, physicists have discovered that the two initial pairs of entangled photons don’t have to be created at the same time in order for projective measurement to work. This is how the Israeli researchers were able to entangle particles across time.

First they created entangled photons 1 and 2. Then they measured photon 1, which set the state of photon 2 and destroyed photon 1. Then they created entangled photons 3 and 4, and carried out the projective measurement. This swapped the entanglement of 1-2 onto 2-3.

When the researchers later measured photon 4, they found that its state and the state of photon 1 were connected, or correlated. Photons 2 and 3 passed on the entanglement from photon 1 to photon 4, like gears. So even though photons 1 and 4 never coexisted, researchers were still able to entangle them.

The researchers speculated on some of the possibilities of this finding. Measuring photon 1 may have set the future state of photon 4, or measuring photon 4 may have set the state of photon 1 in the past. Either way, this experiment shows that what happens at the quantum level doesn’t always mesh with our everyday concepts of space and time.

However, Einstein had already disposed of Newton’s idea of events happening at the same time, or simultaneity. His general theory of relativity showed that “when” something occurs depends on where you are in relation to what you are observing, or your frame of reference. So saying that two events happen “at the same time” doesn’t really work at a metaphysical level. It’s clear, though, that the particles, their properties, and the events that occurred during the experiment do exist. These are not under debate. What’s less certain is which properties should be assigned to the particles and when.

But this may be less important when you let go of the common view of time that gets us through our day. Elise Crull, an assistant professor in history and philosophy of science at the City College of New York, suggests on Aeon  that these kinds of mind-boggling mysteries about entangled particles are more “disagreements about labeling, brought about by relativity.” Although spatial and temporal entanglement may make us uncomfortable at times, Crull says that we can’t afford to ignore these findings in whatever metaphysics we develop in the future.


#64 AI and the Global Brain

Podcast with

Trying to wrap our minds, hearts, and bodies around the rapidly evolving field of AI

Decolonizing Science

Article by

We are witnessing a resurgence of indigenous knowledge and growing acknowledgement of its scientific value worldwide

Wholeness & Fragmentation

Video with

The problem with our "civilized" and compartmentalized ways of thinking, which is fragmented.

Assembly Theory

Article by

Bold New 'Theory of Everything' Could Unite Physics And Evolution

The Star Compass: kāpehu whetū

Article by

Indigenous Polynesian technology for navigating using the stars

#55 Cerebrospinal Fluid

Podcast with

A fascinating lecture on the potential mystical properties of fluid in our bodies

The Convergence of Science and Spirituality

Video with ,

A video version of our popular Sounds of SAND Podcast episode

A 9-minute journey inside a black hole

Video with

Ever wonder what would happen if we got sucked into a black hole? Turns out we could live in it — if it was big enough.

Support SAND with a Donation

Science and Nonduality is a nonprofit organization. Your donation goes directly towards the development of our vision and the growth of our community.
Thank you for your support!